Make a Good Answer Great
Refine weak answers using feedback, comparisons and deliberate constraints.
25 minutes Course overview1. Treat the first answer like a rough draft
Even a good prompt won’t always get the result you want. That’s normal. Editing with AI is a skill: you notice what’s missing, name it precisely and ask for a second attempt.
Think of three quality questions: Is it relevant? Is it clear? Can I actually use it? If the answer fails one, tell the AI exactly how.
2. Give feedback the way you would to a colleague
Instead of “That’s rubbish”, try “This is too formal for a friendly message. Keep the same meaning, remove the jargon and use shorter sentences.” Specific corrections usually work better than vague dissatisfaction.
3. Ask for options, then choose
When you’re not sure which direction is best, ask for two or three noticeably different approaches. For instance: “Give me a warm version, a direct version and a short version.” Then choose the one that fits and explain why.
It can also help to ask the AI to compare options against criteria: cost, effort, risk, clarity or speed. Just remember that the scores reflect the information supplied; they are not independently verified facts.
4. Use the “critic then improve” technique
Ask: “What are the three biggest weaknesses in this answer? Revise it to address them.” You should still check the critique. The point is to encourage a second pass, not assume the second pass is perfect.
5. Know when to stop
Endless tweaking can waste time. Before you start, define success: “I want a polite message that’s ready for me to check and send.” Once you’ve achieved that, stop. A useful result beats a theoretically perfect result you never use.
Try it yourself
Ask the AI to draft a short fictional message inviting neighbours to a community litter pick. Then give four rounds of feedback: tone, length, clarity and format.
Now ask for a version suitable for a printed flyer and one for a group chat. Note what changes and what must remain accurate.
Can you explain it back?
Answer each question before opening the explanation. You aren’t being graded — this is how you make the knowledge stick.
1. What’s more useful than “make it better”?
Specific feedback explaining what’s wrong and what to change.
2. Should you accept a revised answer without checking it?
No. Revisions can introduce new mistakes or alter meaning.
3. When should you stop refining?
When the output meets your clear, practical success criteria and you have checked it.
