Use AI to Compare Options and Make Better Decisions
Define decision criteria, expose assumptions and use AI as a structured sounding board rather than an authority.
35 MINUTES FREE · GOING DEEPER1. Start with what matters to you
Whether you’re choosing a home project, learning resource or productivity tool, the “best” option depends on what you value. State your criteria: cost, time, effort, quality, flexibility, risks and how difficult it is to reverse the choice.
2. Make a decision table
Ask the AI to show each option against your criteria and label unknowns. If you supply example scores, treat them as personal preferences, not objective truth. Do not accept fabricated prices or capabilities as evidence.
3. Invite disagreement
One powerful follow-up is: “Argue against my favourite option. What am I overlooking?” Another: “What single fact would most change this choice?” You want thoughtful challenge, not an assistant that simply agrees.
4. Consider reversible and irreversible choices
Trying a new note-taking method for a week is easy to reverse. Signing a costly contract or making a hiring decision carries greater consequences. The more serious the decision, the more independent evidence and qualified advice you may need.
5. Decide for yourself
AI can organise pros and cons and help you articulate trade-offs. It doesn’t know all your values, obligations or circumstances. Document the reasons for your final choice, especially any assumptions still unresolved.
See it in action
This example shows how to apply the lesson. You can reuse the structure with safe, fictional or public details.
Your practical exercise
Pick a low-stakes choice with two or three options. List three criteria before asking AI. Have it construct a comparison, then challenge the apparent winner. Explain your own final decision in two sentences.
Check your understanding
Answer in your own words before opening each explanation.
1. Can AI decide the best option without knowing your priorities?
Not reliably. Tell it the criteria and what trade-offs matter.
2. Why ask it to challenge your favourite choice?
To surface blind spots, drawbacks and missing information.
3. What should increase as decisions become harder to reverse?
The level of independent checking, care and appropriate expert input.
